Experiment 1
The values were .155 rad/s^2 and .157 rad/s^2 so yes they agree within the uncertainty of measurement.

Experiment 2
The values were .08848 kg*m^2 and .03518 kg*m^2 and they don't agree within the uncertainty of measurement.

Experiment 3
The values were 2.57*10^-4 (rotational) and 1.45*10^-4 (translational) and the final KE was 4.02*10^-4. I think the values agree within the uncertainty of measurement.